Just wondering, why his Support and Crit are rated low? Are Charisma and NP batteries plus success chance not that worth? It's kinda weird because Servants like Gilgamesh with only a mere Charisma and nothing more got 3 lol. And why his crit is low? Being Rider he should absorb more stars than others, and combined with his buff he can deals monstrous damage on his crits, and he can make decent amount of stars with his brave chain with quick card last. I also find some of your stat ranking have some contradictive with the analysis. Eg. You guys give Scat's NP gain at 4, while the analysis stated she has a poor NP gain, so I'm afraid it would make a bit misleading. Thanks in advance
I will admit the ratings aren't the best on this site, I would recommend just looking at the strengths and weaknesses instead way more accurate. I think the critical stat is supposes to be on how many crit stars they can generate since Jack has a 5 in it, I wouldn't put gilgamesh at a 5 maybe a 4. I have no idea why the support is different. In conclusion the stats on this site are weird just use the analysis.
For support, I would assume that it's because Charisma and a small NP charge are pretty vanilla. The buff chance up is really only for his own benefit, to help him proc Imperial Privilege, but obviously would help out other IP servants like Nero Etc. Scathach and Anderson would benefit as well, but there isn't a huge selection of servants who benefit from it. His Crit is because, while he can draw stars, he doesn't have a damage modifier on Crits like most archers do.
Gil should admittedly have a 1 or 2 in support, because all he has is Charisma and he can make like 25-30 stars on a Brave Chain, most of which he'll take for himself anyway.
And I believe they base the rankings on what the servants could do at their best, because yes, Scathach does generally have piss poor NP gain, but with and ABB chain her gain is actually pretty good because of her hitcounts.
" Charisma and a small NP charge are pretty vanilla"
It's actually pretty rare (only 2 others servants in NA have a team NP up skill and they're both high tier supports), and easily puts him at 3rd best farming support (Unless you have mlb k-scopes You need np charge support to farm efficiently).
Combine it with NP seal and Def down on his NP and he is a great support for hard fights.
You referring to Helena and Waver? Yeah, I kinda forgot that the team NP charge was kinda rare, since aside from these 3, I think only Tamamo has it in her NP? Still, while a skill like that may be rare, it's second effect is only useful to a handful of servants. I will say that he should be a at least 3-4 on his support ranking.
Charisma is Vanilla as can be though.
But GP assigns very odd rankings, ones that I sometimes don't agree with, in just about every one that they do.
Hi! While I do agree with your assessment on most accounts, I am slightly hurt by your suggestion that we were high or something.
While we spend a lot of time on the writeups and content, we do not spend as much time on the stat ratings, and thus they will tend to be inconsistent given the author's own thoughts and interpretations. We are working on standardizing things across the board to tackle these issues, though.
We will be revisiting and changing them.
- Scathach's NP gain ranking will be lowered. Her ABB can be good, but it's specific and inconsistent. It's one of the weakest parts of her kit.
- Ozzy is a bit different. I do agree his utility for the team should be higher considering he can do a bit more. Regarding critical, like Gilgamesh the stars he makes are pretty much for himself. Additionally, Ozymandias does not have any critical modifiers, ways to increase star weight, or consistent ways to generate stars, thus his crit score is lower.
Thank you for your concerns, and apologies for any inconveniences.
